Ontario houses, condos and land, live from REALTOR.ca
HouseMLS® listing

$539,000≈ 3,672 sq ft lot

423 MARY STREET, Orillia, Ontario
Listing photo 1Listing photo 2Listing photo 3Listing photo 4Listing photo 5Listing photo 6Listing photo 7Listing photo 8Listing photo 9

About this property

CORNER LOT SIDESPLIT WITH BIG-TICKET UPDATES, A BACKYARD BUNKIE, FINISHED BASEMENT & OVERSIZED GARAGE! 423 Mary Street starts strong where buyers tend to look hardest, with a newer steel roof, updated windows, newer A/C, furnace (2025), owned water heater (2025), plus an oversized single garage and a 10x10 ft bunkie or shed for bikes, tools, hobby gear or the extras that never seem to fit inside. Set on a corner lot in a mature Orillia neighbourhood, this sidesplit has an updated front porch, generous driveway parking and a large backyard with room for gardens, pets or play. The main level offers an open-concept living and dining area warmed by a gas fireplace, along with a kitchen featuring a newer dishwasher. The upper level features three generously sized bedrooms and a 4-piece bathroom, while the lower level adds a versatile fourth bedroom or office and a 3-piece bathroom. The finished basement extends the living space with a spacious rec room and convenient laundry featuring a new washer and dryer (2025). Central vacuum adds another convenient feature. Multiple parks, Harriett Todd P.S. and Twin Lakes S.S. are within walking distance, with the Orillia Recreation Centre, Hwy 12, shopping, amenities and Orillia Soldiers' Memorial Hospital just a quick drive away. This #HomeToStay takes the sting out of homeownership by checking off the big-ticket essentials, leaving you free to focus on the fun stuff, like styling the open-concept main floor or deciding what that backyard bonus space could become. (id:68078)

Details

Type
House
Price
$539,000
Bedrooms
4
Bathrooms
2
Lot size
≈ 3,672 sq ft lot
Frontage and depth
34 x 108 FT
Zoning
R2
Property tax (estimate)
$5,929 a year
If you finance
House: lenders usually want 5–20% down
MLS® number
S14189530

Price history

Nov 21, 2026, current price
$539,000

Rent, mortgage and cash flow

What this house could rent for, and what each buyer pays and gets back each month.
Expected rent
Whole house, 4 bed$3,100/mo
Based on average asking rents in the Barrie area.
Buyers
2
Down payment
20%
Mortgage rate
4.6%
Each monthGroup · Each
Rent in+$3,100 · +$1,550
Mortgage (25 years)−$2,411 · −$1,205
Property tax−$494 · −$247
Insurance (estimate)−$120 · −$60
Repairs, 5% of rent−$155 · −$78
Empty months, 4% of rent−$124 · −$62
Cash flow−$204 · −$102
Down payment each$53,900
Mortgage share each$215,600
Cap rate (before mortgage)4.9%
Estimates. Closing costs and the technology fee are extra. Everyone on a mortgage is usually liable for the whole loan.
The area
Median household income, Barrie$97,000/yr
Sources: Statistics Canada and CMHC, Quarterly Rent Statistics, Q2 2026; 2021 Census, median household income in 2020.

Can this property be split?

A severance (the town calls it a consent) turns one property into two or more, each with its own deed. Groups use it so each owner can hold, build on or sell their own lot. Here's what it would cost here.
New lots to create
1
Town fees
Consent application (typical rural Ontario)$1,500 – $3,600
ParklandSet by the town. Usually a flat amount per new lot, or up to 5% of the new lot’s value.
We haven't loaded this town's fees yet. The check confirms the exact amount.
Other costs, paid at cost
Surveyor (sketch and reference plan)$2,500 – $5,000
Planner (application and justification)$1,500 – $3,500
Lawyer (new deed and registration)$1,200 – $2,000
Conservation authority review is added if the land is near water or wetlands, usually $500 to $2,500.
Titled severance service
“Can this be split?” check$499
Full service, start to approval$2,950
The check is credited toward the full service. Half of the service fee is due when the application is filed and half when it's approved.
Estimated total$9,650 – $17,050
How it works and how long it takes
  1. We check zoning, the official plan and minimum lot sizes, and tell you if a split is likely. About 10 business days.
  2. Pre-consultation with the town's planner, and a survey sketch of the new lots.
  3. We file the application with the town fees. The town posts a sign and notifies neighbours.
  4. The committee decides at a public hearing, usually 6 to 12 weeks after filing, followed by a 20-day appeal period.
  5. You meet the conditions, such as the reference plan, parkland payment and any road widening. Most towns allow up to 2 years.
  6. The town stamps the deeds and the lawyer registers each new lot.
Estimates only. Farmland and land on the Greenbelt, Oak Ridges Moraine or Niagara Escarpment often can't be split for new homes. The check tells you before you spend more. Town fees change each year; the town's schedule is final.
RPowered by REALTOR.ca

This REALTOR.ca listing content is owned and licensed by REALTOR® members of The Canadian Real Estate Association.

The trademarks REALTOR®, REALTORS®, and the REALTOR® logo are controlled by The Canadian Real Estate Association (CREA) and identify real estate professionals who are members of CREA. The trademarks MLS®, Multiple Listing Service® and the associated logos are owned by CREA and identify the quality of services provided by real estate professionals who are members of CREA.

Listings shown through Titled's partner brokerage. Information is believed reliable but not guaranteed; confirm all details with the listing brokerage.

$539,000Buy alone or split with up to 50Start a group